Publication rate of studies presented at the French Arthroscopic Society Meeting in 2014.

Charles Pioger (1) , Julien Dartus (2) , Harold Common (3) , Patrick Devos (4) , Emilie Bilichtin (5) , Marion Besnard (6) , Quentin Baumann (7) , Corentin Pangaud (8)

1 Hôpital Cochin [AP-HP]
2 MABLab (ex-pmoi) - Marrow Adiposity & Bone Lab - Adiposité Médullaire et Os - ULR 4490
3 Service de chirurgie orthopédique, réparatrice et traumatologique [Rennes]
4 METRICS - Evaluation des technologies de santé et des pratiques médicales - ULR 2694
5 HIA Begin - Hôpital d'Instruction des Armées Begin [Saint-Mandé, France]
6 CHRU Tours - Centre Hospitalier Régional Universitaire de Tours
7 CHU Amiens-Picardie
8 Hôpitaux Sud - Hôpital Sainte-Marguerite [CHU - APHM]

Introduction Publication rates for studies reported at French Arthroscopic Society (Société francophone d’arthroscopie, SFA) meetings are not known. A comprehensive search of podium presentations to the 2014 SFA meeting was performed, assessing: (1) publication rate for meeting abstracts, and (2) bibliometric parameters including journal Impact Factor. Hypothesis The full-text publication rate for abstracts accepted for the 2014 French Arthroscopic Society (SFA) meeting was around 47.1%: i.e., the rate reported for the 2013 meeting of the French Society of Orthopedic Surgery and Traumatology (SoFCOT). Material and methods Bibliometric analysis of all abstracts accepted for the 2014 SFA annual meeting was undertaken by the Junior French Arthroscopic Society (SFA Junior), who collated the podium presentations. Reported studies were retrospective in 43 cases (54%) and prospective in 36 (46%). They consisted in clinical studies in 52/79 cases (66%), experimental studies in 4 (5%), cadaver or animal studies in 13 (16.5%), epidemiological studies in 8 (10%), a case report in 1 (1.2%) and a literature review in 1 (1.2%). Thirty-two (40.5%) concerned the shoulder and 31 (39%) the knee. Publication was checked on systematic PubMed-Medline search of authors’ names. Articles found on PubMed-Medline were downloaded into the SIGAPS scientific publication search, management and analysis system database. Journal impact factor and SIGAPS category (A to E) were obtained, as were number of citations and h-index. This was a descriptive study, assessing numbers; results were reported as number and percentage. Results Overall publication rate was 31/79 (39.2%): 20/31 clinical studies (64.5%), 6 cadaver studies (19.4%), 3 epidemiology studies (9.7%), 1 experimental study (3.2%) and 1 literature review (3.2%). Mean 2014 SFA meeting-to-publication time was 18.7 months [range, −2 to 60 months]. Journal SIGAPS categories were A for 4 articles (13.3%), B for 13 (43.3%), C for 3 (10%), D for 9 (30%), with no E category articles but 1 article (3.3%) without SIGAPS category. Conclusion The publication rate for abstracts accepted for report to the 2014 SFA annual meeting was lower than for the 2013 SoFCOT meeting. The high level of the journals in question testified to the quality of the studies reported at the SFA meeting.

Mots clés: Presentation; Meeting; SFA; Arthroscopy; Bibliometrics

Domaines: Sciences du Vivant [q-bio]

Charles Pioger, Julien Dartus, Harold Common, Patrick Devos, Emilie Bilichtin, et al.. Publication rate of studies presented at the French Arthroscopic Society Meeting in 2014.. Orthopaedics & Traumatology: Surgery & Research, 2020, Orthopaedics & Traumatology: Surgery & Research, 106 (8), pp.S189-S194. ⟨10.1016/j.otsr.2020.08.003⟩. ⟨hal-04547787⟩